University of Aberdeen logo

AURA - Aberdeen University Research Archive

 

Same data, different analysts : variation in effect sizes due to analytical decisions in ecology and evolutionary biology

Simple item page
dc.contributor.authorGould, Elliot
dc.contributor.authorFraser, Hannah S.
dc.contributor.authorParker, Timothy H.
dc.contributor.authorNakagawa, Shinichi
dc.contributor.authorGriffith, Simon C.
dc.contributor.authorVesk, Peter A.
dc.contributor.authorFidler, Fiona
dc.contributor.authorHamilton, Daniel G.
dc.contributor.authorAbbey-Lee, Robin N.
dc.contributor.authorAbbott, Jessica K.
dc.contributor.authorAguirre, Luis A.
dc.contributor.authorAlcaraz, Carles
dc.contributor.authorAloni, Irith
dc.contributor.authorAltschul, Drew
dc.contributor.authorArekar, Kunal
dc.contributor.authorAtkins, Jeff W.
dc.contributor.authorAtkinson, Joe
dc.contributor.authorBaker, Christopher M.
dc.contributor.authorBarrett, Meghan
dc.contributor.authorBell, Kristian
dc.contributor.authorBello, Suleiman Kehinde
dc.contributor.authorBeltrán, Iván
dc.contributor.authorBerauer, Bernd J.
dc.contributor.authorBertram, Michael Grant
dc.contributor.authorBillman, Peter D.
dc.contributor.authorBlake, Charlie K.
dc.contributor.authorBlake, Shannon
dc.contributor.authorBliard, Louis
dc.contributor.authorBonisoli-Alquati, Andrea
dc.contributor.authorBonnet, Timothée
dc.contributor.authorBordes, Camille Nina Marion
dc.contributor.authorBose, Aneesh P.H.
dc.contributor.authorBotterill-James, Thomas
dc.contributor.authorBoyd, Melissa Anna
dc.contributor.authorBoyle, Sarah A.
dc.contributor.authorBradfer-Lawrence, Tom
dc.contributor.authorBradham, Jennifer
dc.contributor.authorBrand, Jack A.
dc.contributor.authorBrengdahl, Martin I.
dc.contributor.authorBulla, Martin
dc.contributor.authorBussière, Luc
dc.contributor.authorCamerlenghi, Ettore
dc.contributor.authorCampbell, Sara E.
dc.contributor.authorCampos, Leonardo L.F.
dc.contributor.authorCaravaggi, Anthony
dc.contributor.authorCardoso, Pedro
dc.contributor.authorCarroll, Charles J.W.
dc.contributor.authorCatanach, Therese A.
dc.contributor.authorChen, Xuan
dc.contributor.authorChik, Heung Ying Janet
dc.contributor.authorChoy, Emily Sarah
dc.contributor.authorChristie, Alec Philip
dc.contributor.authorChuang, Angela
dc.contributor.authorChunco, Amanda J.
dc.contributor.authorClark, Bethany L.
dc.contributor.authorContina, Andrea
dc.contributor.authorCovernton, Garth A.
dc.contributor.authorCox, Murray P.
dc.contributor.authorCressman, Kimberly A.
dc.contributor.authorCrotti, Marco
dc.contributor.authorCrouch, Connor Davidson
dc.contributor.authorD’Amelio, Pietro B.
dc.contributor.authorde Sousa, Alexandra Allison
dc.contributor.authorDöbert, Timm Fabian
dc.contributor.authorDobler, Ralph
dc.contributor.authorDobson, Adam J.
dc.contributor.authorDoherty, Tim S.
dc.contributor.authorDrobniak, Szymon Marian
dc.contributor.authorDuffy, Alexandra Grace
dc.contributor.authorDuncan, Alison B.
dc.contributor.authorDunn, Robert P.
dc.contributor.authorDunning, Jamie
dc.contributor.authorDutta, Trishna
dc.contributor.authorEberhart-Hertel, Luke
dc.contributor.authorElmore, Jared Alan
dc.contributor.authorElsherif, Mahmoud Medhat
dc.contributor.authorEnglish, Holly M.
dc.contributor.authorEnsminger, David C.
dc.contributor.authorErnst, Ulrich Rainer
dc.contributor.authorFerguson, Stephen M.
dc.contributor.authorFernandez-Juricic, Esteban
dc.contributor.authorFerreira-Arruda, Thalita
dc.contributor.authorFieberg, John
dc.contributor.authorFinch, Elizabeth A.
dc.contributor.authorFiorenza, Evan A.
dc.contributor.authorFisher, David N.
dc.contributor.authorFontaine, Amélie
dc.contributor.authorForstmeier, Wolfgang
dc.contributor.authorFourcade, Yoan
dc.contributor.authorFrank, Graham S.
dc.contributor.authorFreund, Cathryn A.
dc.contributor.authorFuentes-Lillo, Eduardo
dc.contributor.authorGandy, Sara L.
dc.contributor.authorGannon, Dustin G.
dc.contributor.authorGarcía-Cervigón, Ana I.
dc.contributor.authorGarretson, Alexis C.
dc.contributor.authorGe, Xuezhen
dc.contributor.authorGeary, William L.
dc.contributor.authorGéron, Charly
dc.contributor.authorGilles, Marc
dc.contributor.authorGirndt, Antje
dc.contributor.authorGliksman, Daniel
dc.contributor.authorGoldspiel, Harrison B.
dc.contributor.authorGomes, Dylan G.E.
dc.contributor.authorGood, Megan Kate
dc.contributor.authorGoslee, Sarah C.
dc.contributor.authorGosnell, J. Stephen
dc.contributor.authorGrames, Eliza M.
dc.contributor.authorGratton, Paolo
dc.contributor.authorGrebe, Nicholas M.
dc.contributor.authorGreenler, Skye M.
dc.contributor.authorGriffioen, Maaike
dc.contributor.authorGriffith, Daniel M.
dc.contributor.authorGriffith, Frances J.
dc.contributor.authorGrossman, Jake J.
dc.contributor.authorGüncan, Ali
dc.contributor.authorHaesen, Stef
dc.contributor.authorHagan, James G.
dc.contributor.authorHager, Heather A.
dc.contributor.authorHarris, Jonathan Philo
dc.contributor.authorHarrison, Natasha Dean
dc.contributor.authorHasnain, Sarah Syedia
dc.contributor.authorHavird, Justin Chase
dc.contributor.authorHeaton, Andrew J.
dc.contributor.authorHerrera-Chaustre, María Laura
dc.contributor.authorHoward, Tanner J.
dc.contributor.authorHsu, Bin Yan
dc.contributor.authorIannarilli, Fabiola
dc.contributor.authorIranzo, Esperanza C.
dc.contributor.authorIverson, Erik N.K.
dc.contributor.authorJimoh, Saheed Olaide
dc.contributor.authorJohnson, Douglas H.
dc.contributor.authorJohnsson, Martin
dc.contributor.authorJorna, Jesse
dc.contributor.authorJucker, Tommaso
dc.contributor.authorJung, Martin
dc.contributor.authorKačergytė, Ineta
dc.contributor.authorKaltz, Oliver
dc.contributor.authorKe, Alison
dc.contributor.authorKelly, Clint D.
dc.contributor.authorKeogan, Katharine
dc.contributor.authorKeppeler, Friedrich Wolfgang
dc.contributor.authorKillion, Alexander K.
dc.contributor.authorKim, Dongmin
dc.contributor.authorKochan, David P.
dc.contributor.authorKorsten, Peter
dc.contributor.authorKothari, Shan
dc.contributor.authorKuppler, Jonas
dc.contributor.authorKusch, Jillian M.
dc.contributor.authorLagisz, Malgorzata
dc.contributor.authorLalla, Kristen Marianne
dc.contributor.authorLarkin, Daniel J.
dc.contributor.authorLarson, Courtney L.
dc.contributor.authorLauck, Katherine S.
dc.contributor.authorLauterbur, M. Elise
dc.contributor.authorLaw, Alan
dc.contributor.authorLéandri-Breton, Don Jean
dc.contributor.authorLembrechts, Jonas J.
dc.contributor.authorL’Herpiniere, Kiara
dc.contributor.authorLievens, Eva J.P.
dc.contributor.authorde Lima, Daniela Oliveira
dc.contributor.authorLindsay, Shane
dc.contributor.authorLuquet, Martin
dc.contributor.authorMacLeod, Ross
dc.contributor.authorMacphie, Kirsty H.
dc.contributor.authorMagellan, Kit
dc.contributor.authorMair, Magdalena M.
dc.contributor.authorMalm, Lisa E.
dc.contributor.authorMammola, Stefano
dc.contributor.authorMandeville, Caitlin P.
dc.contributor.authorManhart, Michael
dc.contributor.authorManrique-Garzon, Laura Milena
dc.contributor.authorMäntylä, Elina
dc.contributor.authorMarchand, Philippe
dc.contributor.authorMarshall, Benjamin Michael
dc.contributor.authorMartin, Charles A.
dc.contributor.authorMartin, Dominic Andreas
dc.contributor.authorMartin, Jake Mitchell
dc.contributor.authorMartinig, April Robin
dc.contributor.authorMcCallum, Erin S.
dc.contributor.authorMcCauley, Mark
dc.contributor.authorMcNew, Sabrina M.
dc.contributor.authorMeiners, Scott J.
dc.contributor.authorMerkling, Thomas
dc.contributor.authorMichelangeli, Marcus
dc.contributor.authorMoiron, Maria
dc.contributor.authorMoreira, Bruno
dc.contributor.authorMortensen, Jennifer
dc.contributor.authorMos, Benjamin
dc.contributor.authorMuraina, Taofeek Olatunbosun
dc.contributor.authorMurphy, Penelope Wrenn
dc.contributor.authorNelli, Luca
dc.contributor.authorNiemelä, Petri
dc.contributor.authorNightingale, Josh
dc.contributor.authorNilsonne, Gustav
dc.contributor.authorNolazco, Sergio
dc.contributor.authorNooten, Sabine S.
dc.contributor.authorNovotny, Jessie Lanterman
dc.contributor.authorOlin, Agnes Birgitta
dc.contributor.authorOrgan, Chris L.
dc.contributor.authorOstevik, Kate L.
dc.contributor.authorPalacio, Facundo Xavier
dc.contributor.authorPaquet, Matthieu
dc.contributor.authorParker, Darren James
dc.contributor.authorPascall, David J.
dc.contributor.authorPasquarella, Valerie J.
dc.contributor.authorPaterson, John Harold
dc.contributor.authorPayo-Payo, Ana
dc.contributor.authorPedersen, Karen Marie
dc.contributor.authorPerez, Grégoire
dc.contributor.authorPerry, Kayla I.
dc.contributor.authorPottier, Patrice
dc.contributor.authorProulx, Michael J.
dc.contributor.authorProulx, Raphaël
dc.contributor.authorPruett, Jessica L.
dc.contributor.authorRamananjato, Veronarindra
dc.contributor.authorRandimbiarison, Finaritra Tolotra
dc.contributor.authorRazafindratsima, Onja H.
dc.contributor.authorRennison, Diana J.
dc.contributor.authorRiva, Federico
dc.contributor.authorRiyahi, Sepand
dc.contributor.authorRoast, Michael James
dc.contributor.authorRocha, Felipe Pereira
dc.contributor.authorRoche, Dominique G.
dc.contributor.authorRomán-Palacios, Cristian
dc.contributor.authorRosenberg, Michael S.
dc.contributor.authorRoss, Jessica
dc.contributor.authorRowland, Freya E.
dc.contributor.authorRugemalila, Deusdedith
dc.contributor.authorRussell, Avery L.
dc.contributor.authorRuuskanen, Suvi
dc.contributor.authorSaccone, Patrick
dc.contributor.authorSadeh, Asaf
dc.contributor.authorSalazar, Stephen M.
dc.contributor.authorSales, Kris
dc.contributor.authorSalmón, Pablo
dc.contributor.authorSánchez-Tójar, Alfredo
dc.contributor.authorSantos, Leticia Pereira
dc.contributor.authorSantostefano, Francesca
dc.contributor.authorSchilling, Hayden T.
dc.contributor.authorSchmidt, Marcus
dc.contributor.authorSchmoll, Tim
dc.contributor.authorSchneider, Adam C.
dc.contributor.authorSchrock, Allie E.
dc.contributor.authorSchroeder, Julia
dc.contributor.authorSchtickzelle, Nicolas
dc.contributor.authorSchultz, Nick L.
dc.contributor.authorScott, Drew A.
dc.contributor.authorScroggie, Michael Peter
dc.contributor.authorShapiro, Julie Teresa
dc.contributor.authorSharma, Nitika
dc.contributor.authorShearer, Caroline L.
dc.contributor.authorSimón, Diego
dc.contributor.authorSitvarin, Michael I.
dc.contributor.authorSkupien, Fabrício Luiz
dc.contributor.authorSlinn, Heather Lea
dc.contributor.authorSmith, Grania Polly
dc.contributor.authorSmith, Jeremy A.
dc.contributor.authorSollmann, Rahel
dc.contributor.authorWhitney, Kaitlin Stack
dc.contributor.authorStill, Shannon Michael
dc.contributor.authorStuber, Erica F.
dc.contributor.authorSutton, Guy F.
dc.contributor.authorSwallow, Ben
dc.contributor.authorTaff, Conor Claverie
dc.contributor.authorTakola, Elina
dc.contributor.authorTanentzap, Andrew J.
dc.contributor.authorTarjuelo, Rocío
dc.contributor.authorTelford, Richard J.
dc.contributor.authorThawley, Christopher J.
dc.contributor.authorThierry, Hugo
dc.contributor.authorThomson, Jacqueline
dc.contributor.authorTidau, Svenja
dc.contributor.authorTompkins, Emily M.
dc.contributor.authorTortorelli, Claire Marie
dc.contributor.authorTrlica, Andrew
dc.contributor.authorTurnell, Biz R.
dc.contributor.authorUrban, Lara
dc.contributor.authorVan de Vondel, Stijn
dc.contributor.authorvan der Wal, Jessica Eva Megan
dc.contributor.authorVan Eeckhoven, Jens
dc.contributor.authorvan Oordt, Francis
dc.contributor.authorVanderwel, K. Michelle
dc.contributor.authorVanderwel, Mark C.
dc.contributor.authorVanderwolf, Karen J.
dc.contributor.authorVélez, Juliana
dc.contributor.authorVergara-Florez, Diana Carolina
dc.contributor.authorVerrelli, Brian C.
dc.contributor.authorVieira, Marcus Vinícius
dc.contributor.authorVillamil, Nora
dc.contributor.authorVitali, Valerio
dc.contributor.authorVollering, Julien
dc.contributor.authorWalker, Jeffrey
dc.contributor.authorWalker, Xanthe J.
dc.contributor.authorWalter, Jonathan A.
dc.contributor.authorWaryszak, Pawel
dc.contributor.authorWeaver, Ryan J.
dc.contributor.authorWedegärtner, Ronja E.M.
dc.contributor.authorWeller, Daniel L.
dc.contributor.authorWhelan, Shannon
dc.contributor.authorWhite, Rachel Louise
dc.contributor.authorWolfson, David William
dc.contributor.authorWood, Andrew
dc.contributor.authorYanco, Scott W.
dc.contributor.authorYen, Jian D.L.
dc.contributor.authorYoungflesh, Casey
dc.contributor.authorZilio, Giacomo
dc.contributor.authorZimmer, Cédric
dc.contributor.authorZimmerman, Gregory Mark
dc.contributor.authorZitomer, Rachel A.
dc.contributor.institutionUniversity of Aberdeen.Biological Sciencesen
dc.date.accessioned2025-11-03T16:39:01Z
dc.date.issued2025
dc.description© The Author(s) 2025.en
dc.description.statusPeer revieweden
dc.format.extent36
dc.format.extent2739794
dc.identifier302728190
dc.identifier0531a8e3-72ad-45f6-960b-4ab00f9970ca
dc.identifier85218290951
dc.identifier39915771
dc.identifier.citationGould, E, Fraser, H S, Parker, T H, Nakagawa, S, Griffith, S C, Vesk, P A, Fidler, F, Hamilton, D G, Abbey-Lee, R N, Abbott, J K, Aguirre, L A, Alcaraz, C, Aloni, I, Altschul, D, Arekar, K, Atkins, J W, Atkinson, J, Baker, C M, Barrett, M, Bell, K, Bello, S K, Beltrán, I, Berauer, B J, Bertram, M G, Billman, P D, Blake, C K, Blake, S, Bliard, L, Bonisoli-Alquati, A, Bonnet, T, Bordes, C N M, Bose, A P H, Botterill-James, T, Boyd, M A, Boyle, S A, Bradfer-Lawrence, T, Bradham, J, Brand, J A, Brengdahl, M I, Bulla, M, Bussière, L, Camerlenghi, E, Campbell, S E, Campos, L L F, Caravaggi, A, Cardoso, P, Carroll, C J W, Catanach, T A, Chen, X, Chik, H Y J, Choy, E S, Christie, A P, Chuang, A, Chunco, A J, Clark, B L, Contina, A, Covernton, G A, Cox, M P, Cressman, K A, Crotti, M, Crouch, C D, D’Amelio, P B, de Sousa, A A, Döbert, T F, Dobler, R, Dobson, A J, Doherty, T S, Drobniak, S M, Duffy, A G, Duncan, A B, Dunn, R P, Dunning, J, Dutta, T, Eberhart-Hertel, L, Elmore, J A, Elsherif, M M, English, H M, Ensminger, D C, Ernst, U R, Ferguson, S M, Fernandez-Juricic, E, Ferreira-Arruda, T, Fieberg, J, Finch, E A, Fiorenza, E A, Fisher, D N, Fontaine, A, Forstmeier, W, Fourcade, Y, Frank, G S, Freund, C A, Fuentes-Lillo, E, Gandy, S L, Gannon, D G, García-Cervigón, A I, Garretson, A C, Ge, X, Geary, W L, Géron, C, Gilles, M, Girndt, A, Gliksman, D, Goldspiel, H B, Gomes, D G E, Good, M K, Goslee, S C, Gosnell, J S, Grames, E M, Gratton, P, Grebe, N M, Greenler, S M, Griffioen, M, Griffith, D M, Griffith, F J, Grossman, J J, Güncan, A, Haesen, S, Hagan, J G, Hager, H A, Harris, J P, Harrison, N D, Hasnain, S S, Havird, J C, Heaton, A J, Herrera-Chaustre, M L, Howard, T J, Hsu, B Y, Iannarilli, F, Iranzo, E C, Iverson, E N K, Jimoh, S O, Johnson, D H, Johnsson, M, Jorna, J, Jucker, T, Jung, M, Kačergytė, I, Kaltz, O, Ke, A, Kelly, C D, Keogan, K, Keppeler, F W, Killion, A K, Kim, D, Kochan, D P, Korsten, P, Kothari, S, Kuppler, J, Kusch, J M, Lagisz, M, Lalla, K M, Larkin, D J, Larson, C L, Lauck, K S, Lauterbur, M E, Law, A, Léandri-Breton, D J, Lembrechts, J J, L’Herpiniere, K, Lievens, E J P, de Lima, D O, Lindsay, S, Luquet, M, MacLeod, R, Macphie, K H, Magellan, K, Mair, M M, Malm, L E, Mammola, S, Mandeville, C P, Manhart, M, Manrique-Garzon, L M, Mäntylä, E, Marchand, P, Marshall, B M, Martin, C A, Martin, D A, Martin, J M, Martinig, A R, McCallum, E S, McCauley, M, McNew, S M, Meiners, S J, Merkling, T, Michelangeli, M, Moiron, M, Moreira, B, Mortensen, J, Mos, B, Muraina, T O, Murphy, P W, Nelli, L, Niemelä, P, Nightingale, J, Nilsonne, G, Nolazco, S, Nooten, S S, Novotny, J L, Olin, A B, Organ, C L, Ostevik, K L, Palacio, F X, Paquet, M, Parker, D J, Pascall, D J, Pasquarella, V J, Paterson, J H, Payo-Payo, A, Pedersen, K M, Perez, G, Perry, K I, Pottier, P, Proulx, M J, Proulx, R, Pruett, J L, Ramananjato, V, Randimbiarison, F T, Razafindratsima, O H, Rennison, D J, Riva, F, Riyahi, S, Roast, M J, Rocha, F P, Roche, D G, Román-Palacios, C, Rosenberg, M S, Ross, J, Rowland, F E, Rugemalila, D, Russell, A L, Ruuskanen, S, Saccone, P, Sadeh, A, Salazar, S M, Sales, K, Salmón, P, Sánchez-Tójar, A, Santos, L P, Santostefano, F, Schilling, H T, Schmidt, M, Schmoll, T, Schneider, A C, Schrock, A E, Schroeder, J, Schtickzelle, N, Schultz, N L, Scott, D A, Scroggie, M P, Shapiro, J T, Sharma, N, Shearer, C L, Simón, D, Sitvarin, M I, Skupien, F L, Slinn, H L, Smith, G P, Smith, J A, Sollmann, R, Whitney, K S, Still, S M, Stuber, E F, Sutton, G F, Swallow, B, Taff, C C, Takola, E, Tanentzap, A J, Tarjuelo, R, Telford, R J, Thawley, C J, Thierry, H, Thomson, J, Tidau, S, Tompkins, E M, Tortorelli, C M, Trlica, A, Turnell, B R, Urban, L, Van de Vondel, S, van der Wal, J E M, Van Eeckhoven, J, van Oordt, F, Vanderwel, K M, Vanderwel, M C, Vanderwolf, K J, Vélez, J, Vergara-Florez, D C, Verrelli, B C, Vieira, M V, Villamil, N, Vitali, V, Vollering, J, Walker, J, Walker, X J, Walter, J A, Waryszak, P, Weaver, R J, Wedegärtner, R E M, Weller, D L, Whelan, S, White, R L, Wolfson, D W, Wood, A, Yanco, S W, Yen, J D L, Youngflesh, C, Zilio, G, Zimmer, C, Zimmerman, G M & Zitomer, R A 2025, 'Same data, different analysts : variation in effect sizes due to analytical decisions in ecology and evolutionary biology', BMC Biology, vol. 23, no. 1, 35. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12915-024-02101-xen
dc.identifier.doi10.1186/s12915-024-02101-x
dc.identifier.issn1741-7007
dc.identifier.otherORCID: /0000-0002-4444-4450/work/181759974
dc.identifier.otherORCID: /0000-0001-5482-242X/work/189626654
dc.identifier.urihttps://hdl.handle.net/2164/26360
dc.identifier.urlhttp://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85218290951&partnerID=8YFLogxKen
dc.language.isoeng
dc.relation.ispartofBMC Biologyen
dc.subjectAnalytical heterogeneityen
dc.subjectMany-analysten
dc.subjectMetascienceen
dc.subjectReplication crisisen
dc.subjectReproducibilityen
dc.subjectQH301 Biologyen
dc.subjectBiotechnologyen
dc.subjectStructural Biologyen
dc.subjectEcology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematicsen
dc.subjectPhysiologyen
dc.subjectGeneral Biochemistry,Genetics and Molecular Biologyen
dc.subjectGeneral Agricultural and Biological Sciencesen
dc.subjectPlant Scienceen
dc.subjectDevelopmental Biologyen
dc.subjectCell Biologyen
dc.subjectSupplementary Dataen
dc.subjectDASen
dc.subjectLinken
dc.subjectSupplementary Informationen
dc.subject.lccQH301en
dc.titleSame data, different analysts : variation in effect sizes due to analytical decisions in ecology and evolutionary biologyen
dc.typeJournal articleen

Files

Original bundle

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Thumbnail Image
Name:
Gould_etal_BMCB_Same_Data_Different_VoR.pdf
Size:
2.61 MB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format
Download

Collections

All research

The Sir Duncan Rice Library

University of Aberdeen

Bedford Road

Aberdeen

AB24 3AA


Tel: +44 (0)1224 273330

Email: library@abdn.ac.uk

Share and keep up to date


FacebookTwitterWordpress